By Andrew Ard, September 30, 2008
Among my current reading choices is a book published last year by John Naisbitt of Megatrends fame. The book, titled Mind Set! Reset Your Thinking and See the Future,
asserts several prevalent attitudes driving our culture today. While
reading the book, it occurred to me why it is so important to discuss
the lack of convergence among representatives, distributors, and other
market players, even as the rest of our industry becomes more unified.
Ive found that if you approach two different manufacturers,
distributors, dealers, or sales reps and ask about their roles in the
industry as well as how they perceived the roles of other players, you
will get very different answers. Fundamentally, its safe to assume
that our market cannot achieve its best potential if we cant agree on
who is doing what, and who is best at doing which function.
Last month at the CEDIA Member Luncheon, the keynote speaker was Marcus Buckingham, author of First, Break All the Rules and Go Put Your Strengths to Work: 6 Powerful Steps to Achieve Outstanding Performance.
In his discussion, he highlighted empirical evidence that shows the
best way to prosper in our businesses is to focus and utilize our
strengths while working around our weaknesses. Though the U.S. leads
the world in this kind of thinking, less than half of the population
actually puts it into practice. Buckingham noted that those companies
that foster employees strengths often have both the lowest turnover
rates and the highest customer satisfaction.
Like it or not, the future growth of our industry is inextricably tied
to the customers we serve. And, while I still hear people wondering why
CEDIA is encouraging the participation of its certification initiatives
among our design and installation members, it seems that if the
customers purchasing our idea of home theater and home automation are
not ecstatic about the results, then referrals and market growth will
be difficult. To borrow from Buckingham, it benefits all of us to form
a consensus about who does what the best.
Fortunately, we exist within a terrific community with passionate
participants. Manufacturers, dealers, distributors, representatives,
and professional service firms, even as their opinions differ, are
making collective decisions about what directions to go in the current
market. What is most appropriate, as we all attempt to arrive at a
unified industry mindset, is that we use these discussions to achieve
better clarity of our individual roles, and not on one of predetermined
outcomes. A more robust, sustainable, and effective market is achieved
when we are aware of one anothers best contribution and capability for
advancing the market. Lets face it, we are not just competing with
ourselves but with others seeking the same discretionary dollars of the
consumer that other markets desire.
Many representative organizations have created their own answers to the
mindset that they and their market partners hold. For example, they
believe in having some form of distribution associated with their
company as a means of getting closer to a developing, new dealer base.
Oftentimes manufacturer principals and sales managers encourage or
discourage participation in a distributor-related role. But how far
should this model be pursued? Is that the role of a stocking
representative model vs. full-fledged distributor? The stocking
representative usually only stocks the lines for which they have
representative contracts; and, often, it is only a fraction of those
lines. The full distributor model, on the other hand, contains scores
of competing lines that provide a supermarket of fulfillment to
installers.
As we move forward with new categories such as Media Center PCs, we
must all decide who should provide the best introduction, nesting, and
cultural arbitration of this category within our market culture. I have
seen manufacturer players come and go already in this segment because
they made significant market decisions from their own mindset, which,
in their cases, did not match the language of our market. Even the
implementation of HDMI in CI, born of the single point-to-point
mindset, is presenting multi-room integration challenges to our custom
markets profitable and predictable delivery of 1080p signals around
the home.
Finally, I will end with the challenge and a call to action in which we
all need to be heavily engaged. The AV specialty distributor market has
increased the availability of just-in-time fulfillment to a growing
market while lowering the cost and risk of lower volume accounts among
manufacturers; and, has even provided better access to resources, such
as CEDIA education. What needs further attention, however, is bridging
the interests of some dealers in becoming closer to the manufacturer
while developing enhanced profitability.
In an attempt to facilitate this process, many representatives decided
to maintain a stocking representative model but not stock certain lines
(so as to not compete with other distributors) enabling them to utilize
more distributors throughout their territory, and therefore, further
amplify sales.
Regardless of the approach, dealers do grow their businesses and become
more refined as business people. As they do so, many dealers want the
option of a direct manufacturer relationship because they see
continuing to sell a focused product mix as a more profitable path.
Many times a dealers profitability correlates with that brands
ability to transition them into a direct account relationship while
keeping their relationship with the distributor sound. The level to
which the manufacturer can rely on their representative to monitor what
is appropriate also has to be balanced by the quality of the
relationship between representatives and distributors.
Clearly, perceptions are evolving. Ironically, many, including
representatives, are rediscovering the benefits of manufacturers
representatives in our market. In large part, this is why my current
efforts include assisting in the creation of a Distributor Action Team
for CEDIAs Associate and Affiliate Member Council. Lets keep the
dialogue going.
|